Now if they can fix their compensation plan to eliminate the pyramid scheme in which 99% of associates who joined the business opportunity with the intent to make money actually end up losing money. Those with no intent to make money sign up as preferred customers. All associates are required to continually purchase over $100 worth of product every 28 days in order to participate in the business venture. Those mandatory purchases pay out commission to the upline associates. However, the associate making those purchases receive no commission even if they retail the product. This is why I believe USANA is a pyramid scheme.
The FTC made the following statement regarding pyramid schemes:
"...a multi-level compensation system funded primarily by payments made for the right to participate in the venture is an illegal pyramid scheme." - Staff Advisory Opinion - Pyramid Scheme AnalysisNow one of USANA's very top associates who claims to have made over $4 million as a USANA distributor recently made the following statement when explaining to team members whether they should join as distributors or non-distributors:
"Our recommendation, unless you plan to make a lot of retail sales (which most Associates don’t, because of the USANA PC Program), would be to enroll as a non-Distributor Associate, since you would be charged sales tax on the lower, Wholesale, rather than Retail, prices of taxable items for your location." - Distributor or Non-Distributor Associate - by Pete and Dora Zdanis
So like I have pointed out many times, USANA's distributors cannot retail the product because the preferred customers get it at the same price the distributors do. Here we have a top USANA distributor who has been with the company for 18 years (since the beginning) admitting that most associates don't make a lot of retail sales because of the preferred customer program. USANA has 213,000 ACTIVE associates and 70,000 ACTIVE preferred customers. Since there are 3 associates for every 1 preferred customer, it doesn't take a genius to come to the conclusion that very little marketing of USANA products goes on beyond the associates.
I bring this up to make my point that USANA's commissions are funded primarily by their associates' required 4 week purchases which are made for the right to participate in the venture and be commission eligible. The FTC stated that commissions funded primarily by these required payments is illegal pyramid scheme. I believe USANA can do it legitimately by doing one of two things.
1) Either stop FORCING associates to purchase over $100 worth of products every 4 weeks in order to be commission eligible (you lose any sales points built by preferred customers or downline associates if you fail to make these purchases)
OR
2) Stop paying commission to upline distributors from the FORCED purchases made by their downline distributors in order to fulfill business obligations. The associates are buying product from USANA, not each and every upline distributor above them.
Of Course, USANA will never consider doing either one of my suggestions because it would collapse the pyramid scheme and the company would go out of business in less than 3 months. This is because the only distributors who would continue to make product purchases would be those who actually want to product and not because it is a required business obligation.
So how about it USANA, would you like to make the next step in the right direction?
Is it fair to say distributors are forced to purchase anything? I personally am not involved with Usana but with another company. I think its fair for a company to have minimum volume requirements and other expectations if they are going to give a independent distributor certain rights and privileges. The primary privilege is one of being placed in their accounting software and be processed for a commission check each month on any volume they are eligible to be paid on.
ReplyDeleteHaving such production requires is common in all sales organizations. In fact, outside of network marketing if you don't produce required quotas you get fired! Distributors sign up knowing about the quotas. For companies to pay distributors without such a requirement I don't think would be fair to the company. Neither is it fair to say its a pyramid because of the monthly volume requirement. The FTC has established what constitutes a pyramid and that is essentially an organization that makes no end sales to consumers but only to participants in the scheme. Lets be fair in characterizing companies as pyramids is all I'm suggesting.
Mr. Home Business
ReplyDeleteUsana is forcing the associates to purchase product that is very difficult to sell. The products are 3 to 4 times the price of the local drug store. The Usana associate becomes the end user and the consumer of 80% of the Usana sales volume.
"...a multi-level compensation system funded primarily by payments made for the right to participate in the venture is an illegal pyramid scheme."
ReplyDeleteThis is actually WHY ALL MLM companies require you to BUY PRODUCT. It isn't paying for the right to be a part of the company, it's buying product...instead of buying the opportunity. That is how MLM companies stay legal. Very few, if any MLM's have more customers than business associates. If you don't like the product, if you can't use them yourself or sell them to people, then don't buy them. USANA actually is pretty fair in that if you have customers that sign up with you and spend the $100, you don't have to...not sure how that is unfair, just market the product more.
That said is USANA worth 3-4x more than the local drug store...well maybe. They are way, WAY better than anything you can buy over the counter, that is all crap, literally. But the bioavailabiliy and ingredients do raise some questions in certain areas just as phytonutrients and such. This blogger just has a chip on his shoulder he has no idea what he is talking about, but USANA is one of the better MLMs out there cause they actually make a decent product. Is it worth the $60 a month to use...I just don't know...it is borderline.
Mr Decent Product
ReplyDeleteHow do you know that Usana makes a decent product?
Do you have the test results? How does your math get from $100 to $60. The only way you can get $100 of Usana products for $60 is on Ebay. There the price is $60.
Usana is not borderline. They are fleecing people. Do you say "Bahhhh" when you take your pills?
The only thing borderline is your math.The Price is too high! The associates are dumping the product on Ebay!
A colleague actually invited me to join this and I attended the 3 hour product introduction. Their speakers are actually good conversationalist but if you are going to look at it, the product appeared as well as the organization really perfect which is DANGEROUS!!!! When I tried to get out of the place, some people even hinder me and try to explain again what they have even though I really resist to listen. Because of respect to my colleague,I stayed a little longer but I really do not want to be a part of an org that promises me so much benefits in exchange of a they so called "little money" which i doubt is a little sum. They have me signed a membership but I only wrote my name, address and email and signed with a fake signature. I have no idea if I made the right decision...but I have a feeling that I am.
ReplyDeleteA decent product would be a supplement that cost the amount of a supplement. Not overpriced "pharmaceutical grade" products that are marked up to fund a pyramid. Look into the products closely and talk to someone who has an IDEA of what goes into these products.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, USANA is not pyramid scheme, and it´s the Securities and Exchange Comission of United States who said so since 2008, and it´s on internet of you want to check up on that.
ReplyDeleteSecond, about the product, test results had been done and published in the "Comparative Guide of Nutritional Suplements". The book is published in US, Canada and México, and all of you can buy it in Amazon as i did. 1600 products evaluated there and i don´t see any of the companies listed there complaining about the results.
By the way, look for the "quality" you are truly buying in all those products you can get in the supermarket, you will be truly amazed and dissapointed about it.
I hope mister USANA Watch Dog do publish my comment, i dare him to do it.
In response to the anonymous who wrote "First of all, USANA is not pyramid scheme, and it´s the Securities and Exchange Commission of United States who said so since 2008, and it´s on internet of you want to check up on that."
DeleteThe SEC did not make any such statement. The SEC began its investigation, but they never stated specifically what they are investigating. During the investigation, Several members with falsified credentials stepped down. USANA's auditors even quit. The SEC finally dropped the investigation, but that was it. They never made any statement that USANA wasn't a pyramid scheme. In fact, it is the FTC's jurisdiction to protect sales reps (distributors) from pyramid scheme. The SEC handles ponzi schemes which is more of an investment scam.
The fraud report put out by the Fraud Discovery Institute did not include the FTC as recipients in the report. Why FDI didn't include them is beyond me, but Barry was more interested in driving the stock down than actually using the accurate information many people supplied him with for his report and sending it to the appropriate parties. So when you get a chance, post a link on here if you can find where the SEC stated that USANA is not a pyramid scheme.
You also wrote "Second, about the product, test results had been done and published in the "Comparative Guide of Nutritional Suplements""
As for the Comparative Guide to Nutritional Supplements, I suggest you read the blog posting regarding NutriSearch and Lyle Macwilliam: http://www.usanawatchdog.blogspot.com/2011/12/usana-and-comparative-guide-to.html
He hired a USANA distributor to do the research, layout, and editing. The book is loaded with bias. As for the claim that no companies complained about the result:
Maleluca complained and can easily be found on the internet: http://www.xtend-life.com/Blog/11-03-31/Lyle_MacWilliams_Comparative_Guide_to_Nutritional_Supplements.aspx
Xtend-life complained as well: http://www.xtend-life.com/Blog/11-03-31/Lyle_MacWilliams_Comparative_Guide_to_Nutritional_Supplements.aspx
and I bet most of the companies evaluated don't even know the book exists. The primary buyer of the book are USANA distributors because that is who the book is written for, the distributors. It's all spelled out on my blog article regarding the book.